# How Surgical Robots Avoid Hitting Patients During Operations

> This patent describes how a surgical robot can automatically move its arm to avoid bumping into a patient, all while keeping its surgical tool precisely where the surgeon wants it.

- **Patent:** US 9757203
- **Original title:** Manipulator arm-to-patient collision avoidance using a null-space
- **Owner:** Intuitive Surgical Operations
- **Granted:** 2017
- **Status:** Active
- **Times cited:** 166
- **Field:** medical_devices, robotics, software

## What it does

The system includes a robotic manipulator arm with multiple joints and a controller. When a surgeon commands the arm to move its surgical tool (distal portion) for an operation, the controller calculates two types of joint movements. First, it calculates a 'displacing movement' (Claim 1) to make the surgical tool perform the desired action, using what's called the 'null-perpendicular space of a Jacobian'. Second, it calculates an 'avoidance movement' (Claim 1) for the arm's joints to increase clearance between the arm and the patient's outer surface. This avoidance movement happens within the 'null-space of the Jacobian', meaning it reconfigures the arm's shape without changing the surgical tool's position. The system then drives the arm's joints using both calculated movements simultaneously, especially when the distance to the patient is less than desired (Claim 3).

## What it does NOT cover

- Does not cover collision avoidance between different parts of the manipulator arm itself, only between the arm and the patient's outer surface (Claim 2).
- Does not cover collision avoidance methods that change the end effector's desired position or orientation to avoid an obstacle (Claim 4).
- Does not cover systems lacking sufficient degrees of freedom to allow the arm to reconfigure its joint positions without moving the surgical tool (Claim 1).
- Does not cover collision avoidance with objects other than the patient's outer surface, such as operating room equipment or staff (Claim 2).
- Does not cover collision avoidance techniques that do not mathematically separate the surgical task movement from the avoidance movement using a Jacobian's null-space (Claim 1).

## The clever bit

The clever bit is the ability to move the robot arm to avoid hitting the patient without changing the position or orientation of the surgical tool. This is achieved by using the 'null-space' of the robot's movement possibilities, allowing for a safety adjustment that doesn't interfere with the ongoing surgical task.

## Real-world examples

1. Da Vinci Surgical System
2. Robotic-assisted surgery platforms
3. Minimally invasive surgical robots

## Why it matters

This technology is crucial for making robotic surgery safer and more precise. It allows the robot to automatically adjust its shape to prevent accidental contact with the patient's body, which is vital for patient safety and surgeon confidence during complex procedures. Intuitive Surgical, the assignee, is a leader in this field.

## Frequently asked questions

### What does How Surgical Robots Avoid Hitting Patients During Operations cover?

This patent describes how a surgical robot can automatically move its arm to avoid bumping into a patient, all while keeping its surgical tool precisely where the surgeon wants it.

### Who owns patent US 9757203?

Intuitive Surgical Operations owns this patent, granted in 2017.

### When does this patent expire?

This patent is expected to expire on November 14, 2036, when the invention enters the public domain.

### What is patent US 9757203 cited by?

This patent has been cited by 166 later patents that build on its ideas.

### What problem does this patent solve?

This technology is crucial for making robotic surgery safer and more precise. It allows the robot to automatically adjust its shape to prevent accidental contact with the patient's body, which is vital for patient safety and surgeon confidence during complex procedures. Intuitive Surgical, the assignee, is a leader in this field.

### What does this patent NOT cover?

Does not cover collision avoidance between different parts of the manipulator arm itself, only between the arm and the patient's outer surface (Claim 2).

**Full plain-English explainer:** https://patentbrief.org/patent/us/9757203/manipulator-arm-to-patient-collision-avoidance-using-a-null-space

**Original patent:** https://patents.google.com/patent/US9757203

---

_Source: PatentBrief — https://patentbrief.org. Patent facts are from public records; the plain-English explanation is PatentBrief's._


## Related patents

Semantically similar inventions in the PatentBrief corpus:

- [How Surgical Robots Reconfigure Their Arms Without Moving the Tool Tip](https://patentbrief.org/patent/us/9949801/systems-and-methods-for-commanded-reconfiguration-of-a-surgical-manipulator-usin) — This patent describes how a surgical robot arm can move and reshape itself to avoid obstacles or improve its position, all while keeping its surgical tool perfectly still at the patient's entry point or target.
- [How Robotic Arms Reach Further Without Moving the Tool](https://patentbrief.org/patent/us/9844415/systems-and-methods-for-facilitating-access-to-edges-of-cartesian-coordinate-spa) — This patent describes a method for robotic arms with many joints to subtly reposition themselves to gain more reach for their tools, all without actually moving the tool's current position.
- [How a Robot Arm Can Be Manually Moved While Staying Safe](https://patentbrief.org/patent/us/12064197/system-and-methods-for-positioning-a-manipulator-arm-by-clutching-within-a-null-) — This patent describes how a robotic arm can be partly moved by a human, like pushing it, while the robot's computer automatically handles other movements to keep it stable or avoid obstacles.
- [How Robotic Surgical Tools Adjust Themselves During Operations](https://patentbrief.org/patent/us/12733998/techniques-for-modifying-tool-operation-in-a-surgical-robotic-system-based-on) — This patent describes how a robot performing surgery can automatically correct its movements if the actual tool position doesn't match what it was told to do, like slowing down or changing its path.
- [How a Surgical Robot Arm's Wrist Moves Instruments](https://patentbrief.org/patent/us/12414825/surgical-arm) — This patent describes a specific design for the end part of a surgical robot arm, called the terminal portion, which uses a clever arrangement of three joints to precisely position and rotate surgical tools.
